Adding a credit card surcharge or convenience fee may seem like a practical way to recover processing costs. However, charging these fees can result in significant financial penalties and the permanent loss of your ability to accept credit cards. This article explains the risks of surcharging and a compliant alternative: offering a discount for cash.
A surcharge is an additional fee added to a purchase when a customer chooses to pay with a credit card. For example, a business might charge $103 for a $100 service to offset Vagaro's processing fee.
Although surcharges are allowed in some states and countries, they are heavily regulated and require full compliance with all of the following:
-
Registration with Visa and MasterCard before implementation
-
Strict limits on the fee amount
-
Signage requirements at all points of entry, near product displays, at checkout, and on every receipt
-
Surcharges are only allowed on credit cards, not debit cards.
Even if you are doing all the above, you may still not be compliant and are putting your business at risk. Violations can result in the following penalties from Visa:
-
$1,000 fine for the first offense.
-
$25,000 fine and a lifetime ban on accepting credit cards for a second offense.
A discount for cash is a reduction in price offered to customers who pay using cash instead of a credit or debit card. It allows businesses to avoid credit card processing fees and pass those savings on to the customer. The advertised price includes the cost of card fees, and the discount is applied only when the customer pays with cash.
Instead of risking fines and card network violations, you can legally and safely offer a discount for cash. This method:
-
Keeps pricing transparent by offering a discount for cash rather than adding a fee.
-
Avoids negative customer perception of being 'penalized' for using cards.
-
Legal and compliant in all 50 US states and all countries.
-
Makes marketing easier: 'Save with cash!' sounds better than 'Pay extra with a card.'
-
Allowed on both credit and debit card transactions
-
Free from registration with Visa and MasterCard
-
No in-store signage required.
With a cash discount, you raise your prices slightly to include card processing costs, then apply a preset discount at checkout for customers who pay with cash (or even debit cards).
It’s simple, compliant, and avoids all issues associated with surcharges. See How to Offer a Discount for Cash to learn more.
Comments
6 comments
This article is interesting, as there are other competitor platforms that allow the user to charge the customer the surcharge.
Hey Destiny,
There are strict regulations required to allow surcharges, such as posting signage in the window, counter, receipt, products, etc., registering that you're charging surcharges with Visa and MasterCard, and processing surcharges only on credit cards (not debit). Surcharges are not allowed in many states. Because of these factors and our partners who do not allow this, we cannot offer surcharges.
Thanks,
Jamie
How is it that Vagaro charging us a transaction(disc) fee on debit cards when that is illegal for all merchants? But on each day of our deposit report it's showing as CC(credit card) tranaction type. When it was a debit card not a credit card.
Hi Specidy,
The information you provided above applies to brick and mortar businesses, not payment processors (Vagaro) and card networks (Visa). As the business owner, you are not allowed to pass on credit card processing fees to the customer in some states, as this is a cost of doing business. This practice is called a surcharge and is considered unfair to consumers. Vagaro provides a service and facilitates the processing of your credit card. We then charge you a fee for that service. This is not illegal and is common practice.
Thanks,
Jamie
Hey Jamie, you actually didn’t answer Specidy’s question at all. I have the same question she does, so I’ll ask it again.
Transaction fees on debit cards are federally illegal in the United States. Why are we, as business owners, and myself a small business owner at that, being charged fees for processing debit cards?
Hi Katheryn,
Thank you for following up — I understand the confusion here, and I’ll clarify more directly.
Debit card transactions themselves are not illegal to process with fees. What is regulated is how those fees are handled — specifically, businesses generally cannot surcharge customers for debit card use. That restriction applies to passing fees onto your clients, not to the underlying processing costs charged by payment providers.
When a debit card is run, it is still processed through card networks (like Visa or Mastercard), and there are interchange and network fees involved. Vagaro, as the payment processor, facilitates that transaction and applies a processing fee for the service — similar to how all payment processors operate.
Thanks,
Jamie
Please sign in to leave a comment.